Porsche Cranks But Won't Start? Check the PAS Module
Why your Porsche cranks but won't start
If your water-cooled 911, Boxster or Cayman cranks normally but never fires, a failed PAS module is one of the likely causes. The PAS is the car's immobilizer and alarm unit. If it can't read your key or can't tell the engine computer that the key is valid, the engine computer won't let the car run. The starter still turns the engine, so it sounds like a fuel or spark problem, but the real issue is that the security system won't release the car.
The good news is that you usually don't need new keys or a new engine computer. A replacement PAS can be cloned from your original so the car, the engine computer and your keys all match again. We do this by mail at Duvall's Auto Lab.
A cranks-no-start has more than one cause
Plenty of things can cause a crank-no-start. A weak battery, a bad fuel pump or relay, a failed crank sensor, ignition switch trouble or a problem with the engine computer itself can all look the same from the driver's seat. We can't diagnose a car by mail, so you or your shop need to confirm the PAS has failed before you send anything.
Signs that point toward the PAS:
- The car won't recognize its keys, or none of your keys work
- Alarm or immobilizer symptoms that started at the same time as the no-start
- A scan tool reports immobilizer or key communication faults
- Fuel, spark and battery voltage check out, but the engine still won't fire
If you're an owner without a scan tool, any shop that works on Porsches can usually check this quickly. A confirmed diagnosis saves you from paying for a module you didn't need.
What the PAS module does
The PAS stores your key data and talks to the engine computer (DME) every time you try to start the car. When you turn the key, the PAS checks that the key belongs to the car and then gives the engine computer the go-ahead. If the PAS is damaged, its memory is corrupted or it stops talking, that go-ahead never comes. The car cranks and stalls, or just cranks.
Since the PAS sits between your keys and the engine computer, all three have to agree. That's why you can't just swap a PAS from another car.
Why a used PAS won't simply bolt in
A PAS from a salvage yard or online listing still carries the key data and pairing from the car it came out of. Plug it into your Porsche and your keys won't match it, and it won't match your engine computer. You'd still have a no-start, and it may now have new error codes too.
To fix that, we clone your original PAS into the replacement. Your car's data moves to the replacement unit, so your existing keys and engine computer recognize it as the original. There's no need to buy new keys or recode the engine computer at a dealer.
Swapped engine computers have the same problem. If you're also dealing with a DME or ECU from another car, see our page on ECU replacement and cloning.
Models we cover
Our mail-in PAS service covers:
| Model | Years |
|---|---|
| 911 (996) | 1999–2004 |
| 911 (997) | 2005–2012 |
| Boxster / Cayman (986 / 987) | 1997–2012 |
| Boxster / Cayman (981) | 2013–2016 |
| Carrera GT | 2004–2007 |
Don't see your car? Call 908-777-5741 and we'll check.
Pricing
There are two ways to do the job:
- $695: Program your donor PAS unit. You supply the replacement and we clone your original into it.
- $1,795: Tested used PAS unit from us, programmed to your car.
Shipping both ways is extra. Return shipping is added to your invoice at cost, and you choose ground, 2-day or overnight. For a full breakdown and how this compares with a dealer, see Porsche PAS replacement cost: mail-in clone vs. dealer.
What to send us
- Your original PAS module. Its data is what we clone, so we need it even if it has failed.
- Your donor PAS, if you chose the $695 option.
- Your VIN and the PAS part number, sent with your request so we can confirm the job before anything ships.
- Proof of ownership. Immobilizer work needs a registration and photo ID, or a shop work order.
- The packing slip we provide, in the box with the module.
Pack modules carefully with padding so they can't move around in the box.
How mail-in service works
- Look up your vehicle on our website.
- Send a request with the VIN and module part number.
- Pay the invoice once we confirm the job.
- Ship the module with the packing slip.
- Plug it back in when it comes back.
Nothing ships until we've confirmed the job by VIN and part number. Every PAS is programmed and bench-tested before it goes back to you, and most jobs ship back within 1 to 3 business days of arriving. We're mail-in only, with no walk-in service, and we serve shops and owners in all 50 states. Our hours are Monday to Friday, 9am to 6pm.
Every repair, programming and cloning job has a 3-month warranty. If we can't complete the job, we send your module back and refund the service charge. You pay return shipping and a $95 bench-test fee.
Frequently asked questions
Will my existing keys work after the PAS is replaced?
Yes, that's the point of cloning. Your original PAS data goes into the replacement, so your keys and engine computer recognize it as the original unit.
Can you tell me if the PAS is my problem?
We can't diagnose a car by mail. You or your shop need to confirm the PAS has failed before sending it in. Rule out the common causes like the battery, fuel delivery and sensors first, and check for immobilizer or key faults with a scan tool.
Can you delete the immobilizer instead?
No. We don't do immobilizer deletes. We restore the factory security system so the car starts with its own keys, the way Porsche built it.
Get your Porsche running again
If your shop has confirmed the PAS is why your Porsche cranks but won't start, start a Porsche PAS replacement order on our website, call 908-777-5741, or email sales@duvallsautolab.com with your VIN and PAS part number. We'll confirm the job and walk you through shipping.
